★★★☆☆
I’m still so bitter over this book because it had so much potential and it turned out a bit bland.
I’ve read this book for #sapphicathon and it was the first book I’ve finished for this readathon. I was excited about reading a Hades/Persephone f/f retelling. I thought fem!Hades would be the most badass and amazing thing because I’ve always thought it unfair that neither of the three strongest gods from Olympus is a woman. This book was changing things and I adored the idea, but the execution was bad.
Good Things :
- f/f romance that was very cute and it was a slow-burn too!!! I just really loved how fluffy everything was.
- Hades was pretty amazing and I adored her character.
- Zeus was slammed up pretty badly by the narrative and by the main characters. I hate Zeus, I hate how he always gets what he wants, I hate how many unaddressed rapes are in mythology just because the gods are almighty and all powerful and they deserve to be forgiven because they do other good things.
- The Underworld was very different from the mythology, which was pretty original and I liked how the dead were important in the narrative.
Bad Things :
- Persephone was very childish, at times and I feel like some plotlines made little sense. Hades was so much more badass and she was the goddess of the Underworld, yet she hadn’t figured out some very obvious things about the dead. Yet Persephone who had nothing to do with this realm, was the Chosen One, the one who can change it all. It felt like too much at times.
- Athena was put in a bad light and I hated it because she’s my favourite goddess ever and she didn’t deserve to be pictured as an insensitive person.
- Not a lot of plotline. The lack of plot was so obvious that it annoyed me so much.
- At some point, everything felt so slow that I got a bit bored and yeah. This book is the kind where nothing happens for most of the book and then you’re so bored that you barely care anymore when something does happen.
All in all, it was a very interesting and complex idea, but for me, it didn’t work out.
Did you read this book? Did you like it?
Follow me on Twitter | Befriend/Follow me on Goodreads | Like/Follow me on Facebook
I’m still so sorry that you didn’t enjoy this one, because the premise of The Dark Wife sounds amazing. 😪
But a plot where not much happens can get boring and also, why would anyone make Athena a mean character? She’s great and I love her! Maybe I‘m still gonna read The Dark Wife some day, but for now it‘s not high on my tbr list 🙈
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well, Athena wasn’t necessary mean, she was just very indifferent to a past lover of hers, moved very easily to another lover while this other woman was still suffering for her. It was presented more as a misunderstanding, but it still irked me off because I feel like Athena would be more considerate and wouldn’t give off mixed signals either because she’s too smart for that.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Definitely! I mean, she is the goddess of wisdom after all.
LikeLike
Oh no, that’s too bad that you didn’t love it!!! What a great concept for a book. I’ll probably pass on this but I enjoyed reading your review!
LikeLiked by 1 person
The concept is indeed great, I wish there was more plot to it, though. But I’d hate myself if you passed on this one only because of my review, maybe you’ll like it better! 🙂
LikeLike
Hades & Persephone is literally my favorite myth ever! So this one has been on my tbr pile for awhile, and I’m quite looking forward to seeing what I think of it. I love the concept, and I’ve read an excerpt that sounded beautiful, but I’m sorry it didn’t work for you!
LikeLike
I hate it when books have amazing potential but fall short! This sounds like such an interesting retelling, but I think I’ll probably skip it based on your review… Life’s too short for books that aren’t AMAZING (and I don’t read fast enough lol)
LikeLiked by 1 person
I know, it’s so frustrating!!! I was sitting there and thinking “the idea is so cool, why am I not invested in it??” ❤ I highly relate, I need only great books in my life.
LikeLike
I too felt a little disappointed with this book. While the concept was phenomenal, the execution fell a bit flat for me. I wish both Persephone and Hades had more depth to them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m glad I’m not the only one here! That was the issue for me too, that and the fact that I wished there was more plot! But the depth was definitely not there.
LikeLike
I get it why it didn’t work for you. I can see it having so much potential like you said. Thanks for your honest review. 😁❤️
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yess, it was a real bummer!! 😦 Thank you very much! ❤
LikeLike
I’m sorry this one was such a let down for you! I’ve heard amazing things about this book, everytime there’s a recommendation about mythology or f/f romance, this book always come up first.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think it wasn’t that much of a let down, it was more of a matter of expectations. I had high expectations because as you said, the book is highly recommended and the premise is amazing and I felt like it fell short. Maybe someone with lower expectations will love this one more! ❤
LikeLike